Skip to content

Racecards

15:20 Carlisle

News And Star Family Day Novices' Handicap Chase (Class E)

  • 7 Runners
  • Distance: 2m
  • Going: Good to Firm (Good in Places with Good to Soft and Soft Plac
Weighed In
  • Winning Time: 4m 12.30s
  • 7 Ran
Go to Full Result
1
Silk -

Midlem Melody

15/2

    2
    Silk -

    Winter Garden

    11/4

      1
      Silk - Yellow, Royal Blue stars, Yellow and Royal Blue halved sleeves, Yellow cap

      Panmure (IRE)

      8
      2/1
      • Form P0U-511
      • Age 7
      • Weight 11-12

      held up, ridden 4 out, soon weakened, tailed off from next

      2
      Silk - Dark Green, Light Green sleeves and cap

      Clingstone

      242
      14/1
      • Form 06/25P-
      • Age 7
      • Weight 11-11

      chased leaders, left in lead 5th, ridden approaching 3 out, headed approaching 2 out, weakened flat

      3
      Silk - RED, BLACK armlets

      Fiery Peace

      26
      15/2
      • Form F0-2342
      • Age 6
      • Weight 11-7

      mistakes, in rear, blundered 7th, ridden and headway 4 out, jumped right 3 out and next, no extra towards finish

      4
      Silk - Maroon and White stripes, Maroon sleeves, White armlets, Maroon cap

      Winter Garden

      141
      11/4
      • Form 0-32322
      • Age 9
      • Weight 11-6

      led, jumped slowly 1st, headed after 2nd, chased leader, ridden and outpaced 4 out, rallied approaching last, kept on to take 2nd flat

      5
      Silk - EMERALD GREEN, YELLOW sash and star on cap

      Workaway

      195
      9/2
      • Form 315265-
      • Age 7
      • Weight 11-5

      took keen hold, led after 2nd, 6 lengths up when fell 5th

      6
      Silk - BLACK, YELLOW cross belts and sleeves, RED cap

      Father Mulcahy

      10
      25/1
      • Form 34P-P25
      • Age 7
      • Weight 10-3

      with leader, jumped slowly 1st, reminders after 5th, weakened next, tailed off and pulled up before 3 out

      7
      Silk - Red, large Emerald Green spots, Grey sleeves, Red spots, Emerald Green and Red quartered cap

      Midlem Melody

      8
      15/2
      • Form 220232
      • Age 7
      • Weight 10-2

      held up, headway 7th, challenged 4 out, soon ridden, led approaching 2 out, kept on flat, ridden out

      8
      NR

      Native Eire (IRE)

      164
      • Form 1/0B3-6P
      • Age 9
      • Weight 10-0

      Nonrunner

      In depth

      Verdict

      Peter Niven looks to have unearthed a well-treated sort in Panmure and the Course and Distance winner can take care of Winter Garden and Fiery Peace. The Nicky Henderson cast off has had his fair share of problems but the Scottish handler has been patient and looks to have found his ideal trip after much soul searching. Life will be tougher for him in future handicaps and connections are obviously keen to strike while the iron is hot. Winter Garden is game and consistent in his efforts without ever taking first prize. A second to Latensaani at Hexham reads well in the context of this race but his yard are distinctly out of sorts at the moment. Fiery Peace is frustrating to follow. He appears to travel well on the bridle but finds little off it. Workaway could be a much more livelier danger. He won well at Kelso after being given a positive ride and he could get away from them again if the jockeys allow him a soft lead today. With Panmure in such good heart, it seems difficult to oppose him and we will nominate him as our selection.