Skip to content

Can Manuel Pellegrini still become Manchester City's best manager?

Graphic

With Manchester City still in the hunt for three trophies this season, Manuel Pellegrini could yet bow out on a high prior to the arrival of Pep Guardiola in the summer. We take a look at City's most successful managers and where he might rank...

It's been a period of unprecedented success for Manchester City since the influx of Sheikh Mansour's funding, with the club doubling their league title haul in the current decade.

However, the European trophy success delivered by Joe Mercer and his team in winning the 1970 European Cup Winners' Cup still eludes this City side.

Live Capital One Cup Final

So who are the main candidates for the title of Manchester City's most successful-ever manager. Here's the shortlist…

Wilf Wild

Previously a secretary at the club, Wild won both the FA Cup and the league during his time in charge and remains the longest-serving manager in City's history. He took them to the FA Cup final in 1933 before going one better by lifting the cup the following year. In 1935/36, City became champions of England for the first time. Remarkably, they were relegated the following season but Wild remained in charge until after the Second World War.  

April 1934:  King George V (1865 - 1936) shakes hands with members of Wilf Wild's Manchester City football  team before the 1934 FA Cup Final at Wembley
Image: King George V greets Wilf Wild's team before the 1934 FA Cup Final

Joe Mercer

Also See:

Mercer won more silverware than any other City boss during his relatively brief spell in charge from 1965 to 1971. After taking the club up from the second tier in his first season, City proceeded to win the title in 1967/68. The FA Cup followed in 1969, and in 1970 came a double as City won the League Cup and the European Cup Winners' Cup - beating Gornik Zabrze in Vienna. Mercer departed in acrimonious circumstances the next year when a boardroom takeover saw his assistant Malcolm Allison assume charge.

16th May 1968:  Manchester City manager Joe Mercer holds the League Championship trophy aloft after an exhibition match against Bury at Maine Road
Image: League champion Joe Mercer holds the trophy aloft at Maine Road in 1968

Roberto Mancini

In his first full season in charge, Mancini ended a 42-year wait for major silverware when his City side lifted the FA Cup thanks to a 1-0 win over Stoke at Wembley. A Premier League trophy followed in 2012, won in dramatic fashion courtesy of two stoppage-time goals against Queens Park Rangers in the final game of the campaign. But City came second the following season and were surprisingly beaten 1-0 by Wigan in the 2013 FA Cup final. He departed soon after.

Manchester City's Italian manager Roberto Mancini celebrates with the Premier League trophy after their 3-2 victory over Queens Park Rangers in May 2012
Image: Roberto Mancini celebrates with the Premier League trophy in May 2012

Manuel Pellegrini

Pellegrini's first season at City was a success as he picked up the first trophy available to him by coming from behind against Sunderland to win the League Cup in March 2014. There was a strong finish in the Premier League too as City won their final five matches to pip Liverpool to the title that season. But the club went without a trophy in his second season and Guardiola has already been confirmed as Pellegrini's replacement come the summer.

Image: Pellegrini won the Premier League in 2014 and is still eyeing a second triumph

Conclusion

Given the huge financial support he has received, there's little Pellegrini can do to eclipse Mercer's achievements in the minds of City supporters, but that doesn't necessarily mean that the Chilean cannot go down in history as the club's most successful manager. Pellegrini is one game away from adding a second League Cup and, despite recent disappointments, the title race is far from over for his side.

We have an option for the first time for our club to try to reach the quarter-final of the Champions League.
Manuel Pellegrini

City have fallen a little off the pace in the Premier League and are now 7/1 shots to lift the trophy. If he can pull it off, that would see Pellegrini become the first man to win the English crown twice as City boss. But the achievement that would really end the debate? That's easy. City are four ties away from an unlikely Champions League triumph. Achieve that and Pellegrini really would be able to say 'Over to you, Pep' as Manchester City's best ever boss.

Around Sky