Skip to content

Premier League midweek grades: Phil Thompson gives his verdict

Arsenal's Mesut Ozil and Olivier Giroud (right) stand dejected

Did your team live up to expectations? Phil Thompson gives his verdict on the midweek Premier League games.

We asked Liverpool legend and Sky Sports Now guest Thompson to grade each side based on their performance in the Premier League fixtures this week.

So how did your team fare? Did they get an 'A' or an 'F', or somewhere in between? Read on to see how each top-flight side has been ranked...

Bournemouth - B

Bournemouth's Benik Afobe celebrates scoring his team's second goal against Southampton
Image: Benik Afobe made sure of the points against Southampton

Bournemouth were very good on the day. They totally dominated the game (against Southampton) and although they don't like calling it a derby, most people would see it as a south coast derby. They enjoyed most of the possession and chances.

Chelsea - B

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Guus Hiddink says Norwich forced his side into a battle but was pleased with the way they ultimately earned a 2-1 win

When Chelsea went 2-0 up I thought it could be another game where Norwich would fall aside defensively. In fairness [to Norwich] it should never have been a second goal for Chelsea. How the assistant didn't give [Diego] Costa offside is incredible.

Also See:

Liverpool - B

James Milner celebrates scoring Liverpool's second goal against Manchester City
Image: James Milner scored against his old club Manchester City

I expected this result - when you get back-to-back games against the same side - and you play them again a few days later, whoever wins the first match usually loses the second and that's what's happened after the Capital One Cup final on Sunday which could have gone either way. Jurgen Klopp made the most changes so you can argue they had the fresher legs, but Liverpool thoroughly deserved the victory on the night.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Phil Thompson is certain that Jurgen Klopp will be given enough time to help Liverpool end their wait for a Premier League title

Swansea - B

Swansea City's Ashley Williams celebrates scoring his side's second goal against Arsenal
Image: Ashley Williams bagged Swansea's winner at the Emirates Stadium

As the game wore on against Arsenal they got better and they made six changes to save players for the game against Norwich on Saturday. It seems as if the players that came in wanted to say 'I'm good enough to actually start games'. [Andre] Ayew was back to his best, [Bafetimbi] Gomis was better in the second half. I thought Jack Cork was fantastic in midfield and [Jordi] Amat and [Ashley] Williams were superb in central defence.

West Ham - B

Michail Antonio celebrates after scoring West Ham's opening goal against Tottenham
Image: Michail Antonio scored West Ham's winning goal

The Hammers maybe should have won this game by more goals. They've shown all season that they can beat the big boys and proved it once again at the Boleyn Ground. Michail Antonio has not deserved the praise he should do in this side. He couldn't get in the side for the first few months but now he's been absolutely terrific. He's also been a scorer of vital goals. I think this West Ham team are capable of beating all the bigger clubs.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Slaven Bilic said West Ham should have beat Tottenham by more goals

Crystal Palace - C

Connor Wickham scores Crystal Palace's equaliser against Sunderland in the 61st minute
Image: Connor Wickham's form is a plus point for Sunderland, says Thommo

Palace are in a difficult moment although it's good to have [Yannick] Bolasie back, but he needs to get his fitness levels back, and [Connor] Wickham - scoring four in two games is a major plus point.

Live Ford Super Sunday

Everton - C

Ramiro Funes Mori of Everton celebrates scoring his team's first goal against Aston Villa
Image: Ramiro Funes Mori was on target in win at Villa Park

They've been on a bit of a run. I think they've only lost one away game all season and they've had a bit of good news with the investment into the club. Everybody seems to have perked up. They're on a good period at the moment and when they get like this [against Aston Villa] they're a very difficult team to beat.

Leicester - C

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Leicester boss Claudio Ranieri says his side will continue to fight after West Brom draw

It's been a fantastic story. They should have won the game, but West Brom had four central defenders across the backline and made it very difficult. It was a siege at 2-2 in the last 10 minutes. They had great chances when Wes Morgan's point-blank shot was saved by [Ben] Foster. Leicester can count themselves very unlucky.

Live Ford Saturday Night Football

Manchester United - C

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Louis van Gaal was very happy that his side managed to beat Watford when three of their rivals for a Champions League place lost

They probably would have taken a draw but Louis van Gaal's team seems to be riding their luck and coming through games at the moment.

Live Ford Super Sunday

Stoke - C

Stoke's Xherdan Shaqiri celebrates scoring the opening goal against Newcastle United
Image: A wonderful Xherdan Shaqiri strike won the game for Stoke

It was great to see [Xherdan] Shaqiri score with a fantastic strike. He's produced the goods and has been a very, very good signing for them.

Sunderland - C

Sunderland's Fabio Borini celebrates after scoring a 90th-minute equaliser against Crystal Palace
Image: Fabio Borini bagged a stoppage-time equaliser against Crystal Palace

They're upward bound and [Fabio] Borini's late goal felt like a win because it's maintaining the confidence in that Sunderland side.

Watford - C

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Watford boss Quique Sanchez Flores says his side missed a great opportunity to beat Manchester United

Watford had all the chances in this game. It was chance after chance. David de Gea was making all the saves. They should probably had got more out of the game, but didn't.

West Brom - C

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

West Brom boss Tony Pulis praised his side's stubbornness after they drew with Leicester

Salomon Rondon gets the early goal to change things at Leicester and West Brom showed they are made of sterner stuff. They were absolutely fantastic and scored through a great free-kick from Craig Gardner. West Brom, as they do, defended very well.

Arsenal - D

Arsene Wenger Manager of Arsenal gestures
Image: Arsene Wenger's Arsenal side suffer a shock defeat to Swansea

After the first 20 minutes when Arsenal could have been a couple of goals ahead, they scored through Joel Campbell, but it started a downward spiral when [Wayne] Routledge scored against the run of play. Then, in the second half, I just do not know what happened to Arsenal. The passing was dreadful and the players seemed to lack confidence. The booing when Arsene Wenger took Campbell off and brought Danny Welbeck on was astonishing.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Phil Thompson thinks Arsenal aren't showing enough fight to win the Premier League

Norwich - D

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Alex Neil was disappointed with the manner of the goals Norwich conceded against Chelsea

You've seen Norwich fall apart, like against Liverpool when they were 3-1 ahead and against West Ham when they were 2-0 ahead at Carrow Road and then just fell apart. They've been poor and they've been on a downward spiral. They need all the help they can get and if they keep getting decisions like that [Diego Costa] going against you, particularly at home as well, then you're in trouble.

Southampton - D

Southampton manager Ronald Koeman
Image: Ronald Koeman was bewildered by Southampton's defeat

They have been in a decent bit of form. They flip between being absolutely fantastic and a team that can't get a result from anywhere, but this was a dreadful performance by them. Ronald Koeman must have been wondering what the heck happened to his side.

Tottenham - D

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Mauricio Pochettino is hoping his side can recover against Arsenal

As soon as they suffer a defeat, like against West Ham, everybody will now say they're tired, there's fatigue, they're playing too many games, but I don't believe that.

Newcastle - E

Steve McClaren endured a frustrating night at Stoke as Newcastle lost 1-0
Image: Steve McClaren endured a frustrating night at Stoke

Newcastle away from home are absolutely abysmal. Their performance away from home was so poor.

Manchester City - E

Sergio Aguero of Manchester City stands dejected
Image: Sergio Aguero stands dejected after Anfield defeat

You can imagine City would have been celebrating after their Capital Cup win - it certainly looked like it.

Aston Villa - F

Gabby Agbonlahor and Ashley Westwood of Aston Villa show their frustration after Everton's third goal
Image: Aston Villa seem destined for the drop

It was the result everyone was expecting. Out the door in 74 was the big talking point before the game with all the Villa fans heading out. I was surprised they didn't walk out after four minutes because they capitulated. The only joy they got was a Rudy Gestede late goal, but it was another dreadful performance and even playing with three centre-backs, they were all over the place. Defensively this season, Villa have been atrocious.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Micah Richards says Villa have not been good enough this season

Do you agree or disagree with Phil Thompson's midweek grades? Let us know by signing into Facebook below and sending us a message if viewing on skysports.com or by tweeting us @SkyFootball

Around Sky