Skip to content

Team of the season: Guinness PRO12 v Aviva Premiership

Owen Farrell during the Aviva Premiership match between Saracens and Harlequins at Wembley Stadium on April 16, 2016 in London, United Kingdom.

We have put the best of the Aviva Premiership up against the best in the Guinness PRO12 in our head-to-head teams of the season.

Players must have played at least 10 games in their domestic leagues this season to be included. Who wins?

15: Charles Piutau (Wasps) v Dan Evans (Ospreys)

Charles Piutau scores for Wasps v Sale in the Aviva Premiership
Image: Charles Piutau has lit up the Ricoh Arena

Despite the wealth of stock the All Blacks boast on the wing, it's hard to imagine that Charles Piutau would not have boasted a World Cup winners' medal, had he opted to stay in New Zealand in the long run. Instead, he opted for a stint in Europe, and Wasps were the immediate beneficiaries of that decision as he lit the Ricoh Arena up from day one. He will be missed when he heads to Ulster.

Dan Evans v Charles Piutau

112 Carries 237
877 Metres made 1601
16 Clean breaks 18
37 Defenders beaten 53
19 Catches from kicks 87
Source: Opta

Dan Evans' stats for the season are incredible. He carried the ball more than any of his team-mates, making 1,601 metres in the process - almost double the next best, which was 845m from Sam Davies. His six tries were also the most of any of the Ospreys.

14: Semesa Rokoduguni (Bath) v Matt Healy (Connacht)

Matt Healy crosses for Connacht
Image: Matt Healy statistics for Connacht are head and shoulders above his colleagues

When Eddie Jones announced his England training camp squad on Sunday, there was room for Semesa Rokoduguni, and after the season he's had with Bath, it's easy to see why. It's always tough to catch the national coach's eye when your side isn't quite firing, but with 12 Premiership tries - more than a quarter of the team total of 47 - the Fijian-born flyer has done just that.

Matt Healy v Semesa Rokoduguni

12 Tries 9
132 Carries 147
25 Clean breaks 30
38 Defenders beaten 68
1294 Metres gained 1033

Connacht finished second in the PRO12 standings after scoring the fourth-most tries out of any of the teams, with Matt Healy leading the way. The 27-year-old touched down nine times for Pat Lam's men, and made 1,294 metres with ball in hand - the second-most after 1,455 from Tiernan O'Halloran.

13: Elliot Daly (Wasps) v Bundee Aki (Connacht)

Wasps centre Elliot Daly
Image: Elliot Daly offers a long-range kicking option to Wasps

Elliot Daly's rise to prominence saw him capped by Eddie Jones in this year's Six Nations, but there were many calling for his place in the England set-up months beforehand. The 23-year-old has been in superb form for Wasps throughout the season, breaking up midfield defences as well as offering a long-range boot for clearances and three-pointers.

Also See:

Bundee Aki v Elliot Daly

6 Tries 2
251 Carries 99
943 Metres gained 588
93 Defenders beaten 25
7 Turnovers won 4

Bundee Aki was named Players' Player of the Year at the Guinness PRO12 awards, and had already been named as Connacht's player of the year, by both fans and his team-mates, after an outstanding season that saw him score six tries in 26 appearances. His season has gone from strength to strength - a vital key to the Connacht cause.

12: Johnny Leota (Sales Sharks) v Ben Te'o (Leinster)

Leinster's Ben Te'o runs through Osprey's winger Jeff Hassler
Image: Leinster's Ben Te'o may yet feature for England under Eddie Jones

Johnny Leota has benefited from the slick distribution of Danny Cipriani to notch up six tries, but he's been just as useful in setting up tries through midfield devastation. Daly proved that size isn't everything with the way he unlocked defences with his subtle touches, but Leota certainly showed that bulk counts for a lot.

Ben Te'o v Johnny Leota

221 Carries 72
776 Metres gained 249
69 Defenders beaten 16
121 Tackles completed 64
9 Turnovers won 2

Ben Te'o was another award winner at the end of the season, winning Leinster's Players' Player of the Year. He will certainly have awoken some interest from Eddie Jones, but time will tell if the England boss will pick the league convert.

11: Christian Wade (Wasps) v Craig Gilroy (Ulster)

Christian Wade
Image: Christian Wade scored six tries against Worcester

There are not many players in the Premiership who create the same buzz as Christian Wade with ball in hand. His defence has drawn a fair amount of criticism, but he's made opposition defences look chaotic at times with his sidestep and pace off the mark. He's been the ultimate finisher on the wing for Wasps all season.

Craig Gilroy v Christian Wade

18 Tries 12
184 Carries 101
29 Clean breaks 26
57 Defenders beaten 43
1405 Metres gained 930

Craig Gilroy topped the Ulster stats in tries scored, metres made, defenders beaten and clean breaks - an enormous contribution. With a semi-final clash coming up against rivals Leinster, Ulster will want their top performer to bring his best game to Dublin.

10: Owen Farrell (Saracens) v Sam Davies (Ospreys)

Ospreys player Sam Davies kicks a penalty during the European Rugby Champions Cup Pool 2 match between Ospreys v AS
Image: Ospreys' Sam Davies has excelled in the No 10 jersey

Owen Farrell may be No 12 in Eddie Jones' England, but he's been the stand-out fly-half in the Premiership this season. He's slotted 75% of his attempts on goal and marshalled the Saracens attack to the top of the table and a home semi-final. His steely nerves will serve his club well in the play-offs.

Sam Davies v Owen Farrell

152 Points 98
154 Carries 41
845 Metres gained 184
33 Defenders beaten 4
5 Try assists 0

With Dan Biggar at Ospreys, there is no shortage of quality at their disposal, but Sam Davies proved that there is depth at the club too. Biggar edged Davies in goal kicks, his 72% success rate slightly better than Davies' 69%, but the way Davies was able to pull the strings while in charge was impressive. 

9: Will Chudley (Exeter Chiefs) v Kieran Marmion (Connacht)

Will Chudley of Exeter Chiefs looks to offload the ball
Image: Will Chudley has set the tempo for a Chiefs charge

The Chiefs have made it into the semi-finals for the first time in their history, and though there were many factors that took them there, the tempo at which they play the game has played a major part. Will Chudley's ability to get his side on the front foot has dismantled teams visiting Sandy Park, and has set up an interesting play-off tussle with Wasps in two weeks' time.

Kieran Marmion v Will Chudley

4 Tries 4
4 Try assists 7
981 Completed passes 1111
13 Clean breaks 10
12 Defenders beaten 16

Livewire scrum-half Kieran Marmion has pushed his side from the get-go this season. Calm in delivery, the No 9 ensured that Connacht's exciting backs were able to unleash attacking phases while opposition defences scrambled to keep up.

1: Mako Vunipola (Saracens) v Rob Evans (Scarlets)

Scarlets and Wales prop Rob Evans is tackled by Ospreys' Lloyd Ashley
Image: Rob Evans stood out despite a Scarlets slide

Mako Vunipola has been in a tussle with Joe Marler for the England No 1 jersey, and he's pipped his rival in our Premiership team of the season. The loosehead prop was in the top five forwards in carries for the team in the domestic competition with 75, and was invaluable in the set piece. Saracens earned their reputation playing a simple game, and that game starts upfront.

Rob Evans v Mako Vunipola

88 Tackles made 82
10 Tackles missed 13
1 Turnovers won 4
1.46m Average gain per carry 1.43m
13 Penalties conceded 15

Rob Evans cemented himself as one of Warren Gatland's faithful tight five with a good showing in the Six Nations, despite an under-par showing by Wales overall. The strong loosehead has continued that form, though he could not help Scarlets retain their top-four status as they slipped out of semi-final contention.

2: Harry Thacker (Leicester) v Tom McCartney (Connacht)

Harry Thacker of Leicester Tigers in action
Image: Harry Thacker has been pin-point in the Leicester lineout

Harry Thacker's work in the loose has been exemplary, but crucially for Richard Cockerill's side, it does not come at the expense of the set piece. He's thrown the ball in 107 times and only lost seven, a completion rate of 94% which would made a Leicester hooker of any generation smile.

Tom McCartney v Harry Thacker

91% Lineout success 94%
170 Tackles made 91
9 Tackles missed 18
177 Carries 116
1.6m Average gain per carry 3.5m

Tom McCartney may not boast the same lineout success as his Premiership counterpart in this case, but to have a 91% lineout completion when you've thrown the ball in over 200 times speaks volumes. Connacht's backs may be stealing the headlines, but their forwards were laying the foundations from September.

3: John Afoa (Gloucester) v WP Nel (Edinburgh)

WP Nelof Edinburgh  is tackled by Kelly Haimona
Image: WP Nel has been a rock for Edinburgh

It hasn't been the most memorable season for the Cherry and Whites, but John Afoa has shored up the scrum in the No 3 jersey. He was also in the top 10 for tackles made by Gloucester players throughout the campaign.

WP Nel v John Afoa

85 Tackles made 113
16 Tackles missed 14
2 Turnovers won 0
1 Tries 0
13 Penalties conceded 24

Edinburgh struggled this season, but were once again more than solid at the set piece, with WP Nel at the heart of it all. The Scotland international kept opposition scrums behind the advantage line, while also making it into the top 10 for Edinburgh tacklers over the course of the PRO12 season.

4: Maro Itoje (Saracens) v Leone Nakarawa (Glasgow)

Maro Itoje, the Saracens lock, issues instructions during the European Rugby Champions Cup semi final match between Saracens and Wasps
Image: Maro Itoje has already established himself as a big figure at Saracens

Another Saracens lock who stole the ball seven times during the season, and another Saracens lock who has risen to prominence during this season's campaign. His stock in English rugby has risen sharply, with four Test caps the reward for outstanding domestic and European form. Despite his youth, he is already a senior player in the Saracens dressing room.

Leone Nakarawa v Maro Itoje

205 Carries 78
67 Offloads 3
44 Defenders beaten 13
96 Tackles completed 100
58 Lineouts won 27

Leone Nakarawa features for Fiji in the Paris 7s this weekend, which is testament to the style of play he employs as a second rower. He's been a favourite son in Glasgow for some time, helping them to a PRO12 title last season, and a semi-final at the least this year. He is off to Racing 92 at the conclusion of this campaign, so the Warriors faithful will hope he goes out in style.

5: George Kruis (Saracens) v Aly Muldowney (Connacht)

Connacht's Ronan Loughney and Aly Muldowney celebrate after the win over Munster
Image: Connacht's Ronan Loughney and Aly Muldowney celebrate after the win over Munster

In an interview with Sky Sports last weekKruis said despite the Grand Slam, improvement was the order of the day. It's the kind of attitude that has ensured he and Maro Itoje have formed a formidable second-row pairing for club and country. Kruis has become a menace in the lineout on opposition throws, stealing seven throws while taking the ball 43 times from a Saracens feed.

Aly Muldowney v George Kruis

79 Lineouts won 46
4 Lineout steals 7
183 Tackles completed 100
7 Tackles missed 12
181 Carries 50

The flair brought by Nakarawa would be perfectly balanced with the hard-working Muldowney. The Connacht second rower ensured the tight five and pack as a whole were full of grit, but also possessed the skill to contribute in the loose. He will likely face off against Nakarawa in the semi-finals, and as they say in boxing, styles make fights...

6: Jack Clifford (Harlequins) v CJ Stander (Munster)

Harlequins' Jack Clifford scores a try against Saracens
Image: Harlequins' Jack Clifford scores a try against Saracens

Clifford is another young star of the English game. In terms of top individual performers for Harlequins, the 23-year-old was in the top 10 for carries, metres made, defenders beaten and tackles. It's been an all-round contribution from Clifford on the side of the scrum.

CJ Stander v Jack Clifford

151 Tackles completed 91
11 Tackles missed 12
9 Turnovers won 1
3.21m Average gain per carry 4.3m
31 Defenders beaten 18

A fantastic season for club and country, from CJ Stander. Ireland were a shadow of their 2015 selves in this year's Six Nations, but the burly loose forward did all the difficult things all day long. He plays the same role for Munster, throwing his body at a line of defenders several times per game, which earned him this season's Zurich Irupa Players' Player of the Year award.

7: George Smith (Wasps) v Sam Underhill (Ospreys)

Sam Underhill of the Ospreys
Image: Sam Underhill of the Ospreys is a rising star on the side of the scrum

It's hard to imagine that Smith retired from international rugby - for the first time - in 2010. He has arrived at the Ricoh Arena and dominated the breakdown for Wasps, topping the table for steals in a Wasps jersey. The Australian has been a big figure on the field, and will need to step up twice more if he's to contribute to Premiership silverware this year.

Sam Underhill v George Smith

96 Tackles made 195
18 Tackles missed 24
5 Turnovers won 9
3.4m Average gain per carry 2.2m
12 Defenders beaten 20

Sam Underhill is an undoubted talent for the future. Just 19 years old, the flanker has at times out-performed some of the seasoned loose forwards in Wales, including the likes of Justin Tipuric and Sam Warburton. A menace when the ball is on the ground, and a thundering tackler too.

8: Nathan Hughes (Wasps) v Nick Williams (Ulster)

Nathan Hughes of Wasps scores a try
Image: Nathan Hughes of Wasps scores a try

Nathan Hughes qualifies for England next month, and everything points to him featuring for Eddie Jones' team almost immediately. He will have to tussle with Billy Vunipola for international honours, but in domestic competition he has stood above all others. He carried more times than any other Wasps player with 235 - the second highest being George Smith with 83 less - and proved near impossible to stop with the ball. There's plenty more to come from Dai Young's battering ram.

Nick Williams v Nathan Hughes

124 Tackles made 131
9 Turnovers won 7
139 Carries 245
410 Metres gained 922
30 Defenders beaten 52

From battering ram to wrecking ball. The style of Nick Williams may not have been to everyone's taste, but it was almost impossible to stop. Fearless and unwilling to take a backward step, the big No 8 terrorised the fringes of each ruck and maul, and was no slouch with ball in hand either. A loss to Ulster as he heads for Cardiff to play for the Blues.

Around Sky