Skip to content

USTA to review policies following umpiring controversies at US Open

Serena Williams argues with tournament referee Brian Earley
Image: Serena Williams argues with tournament referee Brian Earley at the US Open

The United States Tennis Association (USTA) is to undertake a review of communication policies following a string of umpiring controversies at the US Open.

Swedish umpire Mohamed Lahyani was reprimanded by US Open organisers for going "beyond protocol" when he climbed down from his chair to give Nick Kyrgios a mid-match pep talk during his second-round match against Pierre-Hugues Herbert.

Umpire Christian Rask then came in for criticism after he handed a code violation to French player Alize Cornet after she removed her shirt on court after realising it was on backwards.

The tournament subsequently released a statement saying it regretted that she was given a violation.

On Saturday, Serena Williams was handed three penalties during the second set of her championship match against Naomi Osaka, sparking a firestorm of debate.

Serena accuses umpire of sexism
Serena accuses umpire of sexism

Serena Williams insisted she did not cheat during the US Open final before accusing chair umpire Carlos Ramos of sexism after her defeat against Naomi Osaka.

"Some of these incidents, you know, have prompted us to reflect on the clarity of our own communication to the chair umps," USTA spokesman Chris Widmaier said.

"These incidents will prompt us to analyse ways of perhaps instituting some change. We certainly do not want inconsistencies.

Also See:

"I think it could potentially help everybody if there was some more consistency to this."

WTA CEO Steve Simon
Image: WTA chief executive Steve Simon has backed Serena Williams over her sexism claim

The Women's Tennis Association (WTA) have expressed their disappointment over the handling of the match between Williams and Osaka.

"[The WTA] is committed to working with the sport to ensure that all players are treated the same. We do not believe that this was done last night," WTA chief executive Steve Simon said.

Simon also called for coaching, one of the offences for which Williams received a violation, to be permitted, a topic the USTA plans to review.

WTA backs Williams' sexism claim

Serena's US Open controversies

Widmaier said that the extremely hot temperatures and high humidity, which led officials to introduce a heat rule for both men and women, may have contributed to the confusion.

"The Alize Cornet thing kind of was triggered by the heat but it also brought to the forefront nothing that had ever happened before," he said.

"It prompted us to say, 'hey, maybe we're not being clear here.'"

Mark Kovacs, executive director of the International Tennis Performance Association, said that the officiating controversies at this year's tournament "brought attention to areas of the sport that need to be addressed" going forward.

"Consistency in the application of the rules is clearly needed," Kovacs said. "Currently the umpires have a lot of discretion and many times the same offence does not have the same punishment."

We have every major tennis event covered from all angles via our website skysports.com/tennis. On the move? Head to our app for mobile devices and iPad, or follow our Twitter account @SkySportsTennis to join in the conversation.

Keep up to date with the latest on skysports.com/tennis
Keep up to date with the latest on skysports.com/tennis

We will bring you news, previews, live blogs, reports, reaction and expert analysis.

Tennis is back on Sky Sports screens with the Laver Cup in September while we will also have coverage of the ATP Finals in November with every match live on Sky Sports.

Tennis updates straight to your phone
Tennis updates straight to your phone

How to receive all the latest tennis news straight to your mobile

Around Sky