Skip to content

VOTE: Greatest ever Super Bowl: Do the Patriots feature in your favourite?

Do you agree with our top 10? Vote below and tweet us @SkySportsNFL...

New York Giants' David Tyree catches a 32-yard pass from Eli Manning (not shown) as New England Patriots' Rodney Harrison attempts to intercept

What is the greatest ever Super Bowl?

Perhaps Sunday's Super Bowl LIII clash between the New England Patriots and Los Angeles Rams - live on Sky Sports USA from 10pm - ends up in the annals of history as the greatest?

NFL Super Bowl LIII

For now, we've picked out or top 10, and want you to vote for your favourite out of the bunch below (see foot of the page).

But first, a few honourable mentions for those that didn't quite make the cut...

Super Bowl XXIII: Not quite the most impressive, but certainly the most memorable, of the San Francisco 49ers' five Super Bowl wins as Joe Montana marched them down the field, and toward John Candy, for the game-winning touchdown against the Cincinnati Bengals.

Super Bowl XLVII: Now it's on to the Niners' first ever Super Bowl loss, with Baltimore Ravens head coach John getting the better of Jim in the 'battle of the brother'. There was a blackout in the New Orleans Superdome, adding to the drama as San Francisco very nearly came back to win from a massive 28-6 third-quarter deficit. But it wasn't meant to be.

ATLANTA - JANUARY 30:  Kevin Dyson #87 of the Tennessee Titans reaches for the end zone with the ball as Mike Jones #52 of the St. Louis Rams tackles him o
Image: Kevin Dyson of the Tennessee Titans stretches for, but fails to find, the end zone as time runs out in Super Bowl XXXIV

Super Bowl XXXIV: The Tennessee Titans are stopped on the one-yard line to lose to the 'Greatest Show on Turf' St Louis Rams, after having recovered from a 16-point deficit.

Also See:

10) Namath 'guarantees' it

EAST RUTHERFORD, NJ - OCTOBER 26:  Former Jets quarterback is introduced during halftime festivities celebrating the 40th anniversary of the Jets' win over
Image: Former New York Jets quarterback, Joe Namath, pictured during the 40th anniversary celebrations of Super Bowl III

Perhaps the biggest upset in Super Bowl history only just sneaks onto our list, largely due to the low-scoring nature of Super Bowl III - the 18-point underdog New York Jets beating the Baltimore Colts 16-7.

Despite two heavy defeats for the upstart American Football League - which had merged with the NFL - in the first two Super Bowls, Jets quarterback Joe Namath 'guaranteed' victory, and true to his word, delivered it.

9) Norwood misses wide right

12 Jan 1991: Kicker Scott Norwood #11 of the Buffalo Bills misses a 47-yard field goal wide right at the end of regulation during Super Bowl XXV against th
Image: Bufallo Bills kicker Scott Norwood misses his 47-yard field goal wide right as time runs out in Super Bowl XXV

Perhaps one of the greatest disappointments in sport, let alone just the Super Bowl era, as poor old Buffalo Bills kicker, Scott Norwood, missed the game-winning field goal from 47 yards out as time expired.

The Bills' 20-19 defeat to the New York Giants in Super Bowl XXV was the first of four straight defeats in the biggest game of them all, but was easily the toughest of the lot to take - a certain defensive coordinator called Bill Belichick masterminding the Giants' victory over the best offense in football.

8) Eagles ride 'underdog' spirit

Tom Brady fumbles in the fourth quarter against the Philadelphia Eagles during Super Bowl LII
Image: Tom Brady fumbles in the fourth quarter against the Philadelphia Eagles during Super Bowl LII

You may well be wondering why such a low ranking for last year's stunning Super Bowl LII shootout between the Philadelphia Eagles and New England Patriots - a first of many entries for them on this list.

Several then records were set, including most yards gained in an NFL game by both teams combined (1,151), fewest punts from both teams in a Super Bowl (one), and most points scored by a Super Bowl losing team (33), but it was the lack of defense that hurt this game, until Brandon Graham stepped up with the play that defined it, strip-sacking Tom Brady in the fourth quarter to bring the Vince Lombardi trophy back to Philadelphia for the first time.

7) Belichick and Brady dynasty begins

Patriots beat Rams in Super Bowl XXXVI
Image: Adam Vinitieri (C) celebrates after his game-winning kick earns New England Patriots a first Super Bowl win

Given the upward trajectory that both Belichick and Tom Brady's careers have taken since, it is easy to forget that the Patriots were 14-point underdogs for Super Bowl XXXVI, when they were the next team tasked with taking on the 'Greatest Show on Turf' after the Rams' win over the Tennessee Titans two years prior.

Belichick's Pats restricted the explosive St Louis offense to just three points in as many quarters until the Rams finally found some form in the fourth, scoring two touchdowns to tie the game up at 17. But step forward Adam Vinatieri, who nailed a game-winning kick from 48 yards out in this one to earn New England the first of their five championship titles.

6) 'This one's for John!'

Denver Broncos quarterback John Elway (C) is carried by teammates Ed McCaffrey (L) and Bubby Brister (R)
Image: Denver Broncos quarterback John Elway is carried by teammates after winning Super Bowl XXXII

Don't be distracted purely by the sentimental value of Denver Broncos' John Elway finally earning a ring aged 37, and at the fourth attempt, Super Bowl XXXII was a truly great game too.

It had two quarterbacks at the top of their game going toe to toe, with Elway up against Brett Favre and the reigning champions, Green Bay Packers. Though it was actually a running back who outshone both - Terrell Davis putting in an MVP-worthy three-touchdown performance to see the Broncos to a 31-24 triumph.

5) Steelers topple Cowboys in classic

SANTA CLARA, CA - FEBRUARY 07:  Terry Bradshaw , MVP of Super Bowls XIII and XIV is introduced prior to Super Bowl 50 at Levi's Stadium on February 7, 2016
Image: Terry Bradshaw , MVP of Super Bowls XIII and XIV, is introduced prior to Super Bowl 50 at Levi's Stadium last year

One for the footballing purists, Super Bowl XIII is considered by many to be the greatest of all time, played out between two of the game's greatest franchises, led by truly great quarterbacks, and it was close too.

The Pittsburgh Steelers stretched out a 35-17 lead in the fourth quarter thanks to a four-touchdown pass performance by Terry Bradshaw, but then Roger Staubach threw a second and third of his own to bring the Dallas Cowboys back to within four, but Pittsburgh held on, getting the better of the defending-champion Dallas for the second time in three years.

4) Santonio Holmes in the dying seconds

Image: Santonio Holmes clings on for the game-winning touchdown as the Pittsburgh Steelers win a record sixth Super Bowl

Another Steelers success, this one in Super Bowl XLIII, seeing them secure a record sixth title. And done in the most dramatic of fashion too, with quarterback Ben Roethlisberger finding Santonio Holmes in the back of the end zone for the game-winning touchdown with seconds remaining.

A monster 127-yard and two-touchdown outing by wide receiver, Larry Fitzgerald, had helped the Arizona Cardinals overcome a 20-7 deficit in their first ever Super Bowl appearance before Big Ben's late touchdown strike broke their hearts.

3) Giants stun undefeated Patriots

GLENDALE, AZ - FEBRUARY 03:  David Tyree #85 of the New York Giants catches a 32-yard pass from Eli Manning #10 against Rodney Harrison #37 and James Sande
Image: David Tyree clings on for a game-defining catch as the New York Giants upset the New England Patriots in Super Bowl XLII

It was supposed to be a procession, as the 16-0 Patriots took on the 10-6 Wild Card Giants in Super Bowl XLII, but Eli Manning and co had not read the script.

In an ultra-tight, low-scoring affair, the Giants quarterback marched his team down the field - thanks in huge part to that David Tyree catch - for the game-winning score to Plaxico Burress late in the fourth quarter. The Patriots, and the watching world, were left stunned by what they'd just witnessed.

2) Patriots' crazy comeback

Tom Brady #12 of the New England Patriots celebrates with the Vince Lombardi Trophy after defeating the Atlanta Falcons
Image: Tom Brady celebrates after the New England Patriots' stunning comeback win over the Atlanta Falcons

It may not get our No 1 spot as the greatest ever, but Super Bowl LI certainly featured the greatest comeback ever, as the Patriots overcame a massive 28-3 deficit in the third quarter to tie the game with the Atlanta Falcons in the fourth and then win the first ever Super Bowl overtime.

It took the Patriots till the final two seconds of the first half to register their first points, a field goal, while the explosive Atlanta offense scored three touchdowns. They then stretched that lead further in the third quarter, before back came Brady! Two passing TDs from No 12, plus a James white run - and a couple of clutch two-point conversions - helped the team tie things up late, before clinching a stunning fifth Super Bowl title with another White TD in overtime.

1) Butler's interception

Malcolm Butler New England Patriots intercepts from  Russell Wilson Seattle Seahawks
Image: Malcolm Butler's goal line interception clinches Super Bowl XLIX for the New England Patriots

Following their Super Bowl XLII defeat to the Giants, and another to the same team four years later, Super Bowl XLIX too seemed to be slipping from New England's grasp. Another circus catch, this one from Jermaine Kearse, helped the Seattle Seahawks reach the goal line with seconds to spare.

Trailing by four, surely all the Seahawks had to do was give the ball to 'Beast Mode' running back, Marshawn Lynch, to punch it in from a yard out? Nope. In one of the craziest play-calls in football history, Seattle opted to pass, and quarterback Russell Wilson was picked off by rookie Malcolm Butler in this crazy finish and our No 1 Super Bowl.

VOTE FOR YOUR FAVOURITE

@SkySportsNFL are in Atlanta all week - follow us for live video and a flavour of the madness.

For 90 minutes of Super Bowl LIII build-up from Mercedes-Benz Stadium in Atlanta with Rob Ryan and Bucky Brooks, join us on Sky Sports USA, Main Event and Mix from 10pm on Sunday, February 3.

Around Sky