Skip to content

Joe Hart has no future under Pep Guardiola, believes Andy Dunn

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Andy Dunn believes that Joe Hart has no future at Manchester City after Pep Guardiola dropped for the first game of the season

Pep Guardiola's decision to leave Joe Hart out of Manchester City's season opener against Sunderland on Saturday suggests the goalkeeper has no future at the club, according to Andy Dunn on Sunday Supplement.

Hart, who endured a difficult Euro 2016 with England, was left on the bench as City won 2-1 at the Etihad Stadium on Saturday, with Willy Caballero preferred in goal.

And the Sunday Mirror's Dunn told Sunday Supplement: "The impression you get from the decision he's made is that Hart has no future under Guardiola, it's as serious as that.

Pep's City leave it late
Pep's City leave it late

Late Paddy McNair own goal hands Pep Guardiola's side win

"If we assume the reason he was dropped is because of his lack of footballing skills, then that's not going to change at 29. He's not exactly an old dog but there are some new tricks you can't learn. You can't turn a keeper like Hart into a play-starting sweeper-keeper.

"It's also a big blow to his pride because Caballero hasn't exactly shone or been outstanding when he's played in the past. He was okay yesterday [against Sunderland], but nothing special.

"Guardiola must have seen Euro 2016 and the poor tournament he had. It's a very big decision with a lot of ramifications for Hart, City and for England."

Manchester City's English goalkeeper Joe Hart warms up ahead of the English Premier League football match between Manchester City and Sunderland at the Eti
Image: Joe Hart dropped for Sunderland game
Watch Premier League goals!
Watch Premier League goals!

Catch highlights from all Premier League and Football League games in our Score Centre app

The Times' Chief Football Writer Henry Winter, however, believes it's too soon to write off Hart, and that the skills he possesses still suit the Premier League.

Also See:

"Let's not underestimate Joe Hart," he said. "He's been in this situation before and went back, improved and fought back. 

Live Premier League

"He's a tough individual and a professional. He's not going to become Manuel Neuer or even Franz Beckenbauer overnight, but he will work on this. So let's not write him off.

"This is English football, not like in Spain where a lot of the keepers have time to control the ball, they get closed down very quickly in this league so it's not easy to play the ball out from the back."

Pep won't shut door on Hart
Pep won't shut door on Hart

Pep Guardiola refuses to shut door on Joe Hart's Manchester City future

While the Sun's Shaun Custis believes Guardiola's decision was a clear indicator that he wants to bring a new goalkeeper to Manchester City.

"I think it's a message to the board from Guardiola," he said. "The briefing from City is 'we love Joe Hart, everything is fine and we don't want to buy anybody'. But clearly Guardiola is saying 'you might not [want to buy a new goalkeeper], but I certainly do."