Skip to content

England made decision for Moeen Ali to leave India, says apologetic head coach Chris Silverwood

Moeen Ali's departure from India tour was England's decision as part of rotation policy, says Chris Silverwood, who apologises for any confusion regarding the all-rounder; Head coach says Test cricket is a priority and that resting players now will boost bid to regain Ashes

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Head coach Chris Silverwood has apologised for the way in which England announced that Moeen Ali would return home, and confirmed it was England's decision for him to leave the tour

England made the decision for Moeen Ali to leave the Test tour of India as part of their rotation policy, stressed head coach Chris Silverwood, as he apologised for the handling of the all-rounder's departure.

England skipper Joe Root had said after the defeat to India in the second Test in Chennai - Moeen's first five-day game since August 2019 - that the 33-year-old had chosen to go home and see his family.

However, Silverwood cleared up any confusion during a virtual media conference by explaining the exit of Moeen - who had suffered a bout of coronavirus in Sri Lanka earlier this winter - was always planned.

Moeen Ali (Pic credit - BCCI)
Image: Moeen took eight wickets and scored a quick-fire 43 in the second Test, his first red-ball game for England since 2019 (Pic credit - BCCI)

England are managing the workload of their multi-format players in a year which includes a T20 World Cup and an Ashes series, with Moeen now to miss the final two Tests of the India series in Ahmedabad.

Silverwood said: "We are sorry if the impression we gave was that Moeen is being treated differently to other people. He isn't, I can guarantee you that.

"The decision for him to go home was ours, as it was with Jos Buttler, Sam Curran, Jonny Bairstow and Mark Wood [who have also been rested for parts of the India series]. We're happy to own that decision.

"It was a unique situation with Moeen - he had spent so long in isolation and had just broken back into the team. The question was posed to him [about staying] but ultimately we thought it was the right decision for him to go.

Also See:

Moeen Ali (Pic credit - BCCI)
Image: Moeen will return to India for the five-match T20I series in March (Pic credit - BCCI)

"We touched base with Mo [on Tuesday night], as did Joe [captain Joe Root], and he is fine.

"Mo understands we have got his best interests at heart and we are trying to look after him, just like we do with all the other players. We have to prioritise that and we are doing the best we can.

"It is a strange existence we have at the moment and we need to get on with it. Being locked in a bubble for long periods of time is difficult, especially for people that have got families at home.

"We have to be very respectful that people need time out of this bubble to see their families and, equally, that families need to see the players as well.

BCCI - Jos Buttler (WK) of England  plays a shot during day four of the first test match between India and England held at the Chidambaram Stadium in Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India on the 8th February 2021..Photo by Pankaj Nangia/ Sportzpics for BCCI
Image: Jos Buttler is another senior England man being rested for part of the India Test series (Pic credit - BCCI)

"People do need time to freshen their mind up, so that when they are here, they are 100 per cent here and in a great place to perform.

"One of the problems we have is that if people stay too long and go stale it is very difficult to get them back.

"That's why we try to be proactive and get the breaks in so they don't get to a point where they have had enough. I think it has worked well so far.

"Seeing the guys who have come back, they are bouncing, excited, full of energy. That's exactly where I want the players to be."

Jonny Bairstow - Sri Lanka portal
Image: Jonny Bairstow was rested for the first two India Tests but is now back with the England camp

Moeen will be part of a full-strength England T20 squad to take on India in five games in March but Silverwood rubbished the notion that the shortest format has taken precedence over Test cricket, insisting that resting players now will boost their bid to regain the Ashes in Australia next winter.

However, he did say that giving the T20 side a "dry run" in India ahead of the T20 World Cup in the same country later this year factored considerably into the planning.

The 45-year-old said: "I can guarantee that we are not prioritising anything above Test cricket.

"Test cricket is really important to me. It is something Joe and I are very passionate about and we prioritise Tests and T20 equally.

Joe Root (Pic credit - BCCI)
Image: Chris Silverwood says Joe Root (pictured) is not frustrated that he is missing key players for Test matches (Pic credit - BCCI)

"We know we have a great opportunity to have a bit of a dry run with the T20 World Cup being in India - it gives us a fantastic opportunity to learn as a group and for the players to experience those conditions.

"But we have to respect that to get people to the T20 World Cup and the Ashes fresh and on top form, we have to rotate.

"I don't think there is any frustration [for Root]. Joe understands as well as I do that it is difficult.

"The length of time we are here for Test series compared to a T20 series is chalk and cheese so to play four Tests in this bubble we have to rotate.

"We want to make sure we have a fit, healthy group of players that are all capable of performing in those conditions in the Ashes.

James Anderson (Pic credit - BCCI)
Image: James Anderson was rested for the second Test in Chennai (Pic credit - BCCI)

"We are trying to build a big group of players. The planning for the Ashes started a long time ago and we are continuing to build so that at any given point anybody can play. Moeen is a very big part of that."

England players taking part in the Indian Premier League could potentially miss the two-Test series at home to New Zealand in June, with those dates likely to clash with the IPL play-offs.

Silverwood, though, says he is "at peace" with the situation and believes his charges competing in such a high-quality T20 tournament can only benefit England moving forward.

The former Essex coach added: "I think it is very difficult to say 'no, you can't go and play the IPL'. You certainly can't say yes to one and no to another. If they are playing, they are playing, it's as simple as that.

"I don't think it's an issue. These guys are playing a fantastic, high-level class of T20 cricket which can only benefit us moving forward. We reap the benefits when they come back and play T20 for us

Jos Buttler
Image: Buttler in action for Rajasthan Royals in the 2020 Indian Premier League (Pic credit - BCCI)

"I can understand [people questioning players playing in the IPL and missing Test matches] but I am totally at peace with where we are at."

Silverwood also said batsman Zak Crawley and fast bowler Jofra Archer are progressing well ahead of the pink-ball third Test against India from February 24 - Crawley missed the first two Tests with a wrist injury while an elbow issue saw Archer sit out the second.

Jonny Bairstow and Mark Wood have also re-joined the group.

The pair were rested for the first two Tests in Chennai and flew home to England but are now training again having served their quarantine period after landing in India and in a 17-man squad for the third Test.

Off-spinner Dom Bess is also in that group having been dropped for the second Test in favour of Moeen.

Joe Root and Dom Bess (Pic credit - BCCI)
Image: Dom Bess took five wickets in the first Test but was dropped for the second (Pic credit - BCCI)

Silverwood said: "We left Dom out and gave him a bit of time to freshen up and reflect. He and I have spent a lot of time together since then in the nets and he is in a really good place.

"We know he offers us a lot - not just with the ball but with the bat in hand and in the field and what he brings to us in the dressing room. He is a proper team man.

"If we give him the opportunity I'm sure he will jump at it again. I know he will turn up and give everything he has got which is all I can ask of the players."

England's 17-man squad for third Test against India: Joe Root (captain), James Anderson, Jofra Archer, Jonny Bairstow, Dom Bess, Stuart Broad, Rory Burns, Zak Crawley, Ben Foakes, Dan Lawrence, Jack Leach, Ollie Pope, Dom Sibley, Ben Stokes, Olly Stone, Chris Woakes, Mark Wood.

Follow text commentary of the day-night third Test between India and England in Ahmedabad on skysports.com and the Sky Sports app from 8.30am on Wednesday, February 24.

Around Sky