Skip to content

WATCH: South Africa's Dean Elgar survives contentious caught-behind call against Pakistan

TV umpire Joel Wilson decides Azhar Ali did not take ball cleanly - Pakistan coach Mickey Arthur given demerit point for his reaction

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Do you think Azhar Ali caught the ball cleanly?

South Africa's Dean Elgar enjoyed a lucky escape against Pakistan with TV umpire Joel Wilson deciding Azhar Ali's catch had not been taken cleanly.

Watch the contentious decision in the video at the top of the page.

Proteas opener Elgar snicked seamer Shaheen Afridi behind on day three of the first Test at Centurion, with Azhar wheeling away as on-field umpires Sundaram Ravi and Bruce Oxenford gave a soft signal of out.

However, Wilson overturned that call after studying the video evidence available, believing that Azhar has failed to get his fingers, which were wrapped in tape, under the ball in time.

PRETORIA, SOUTH AFRICA - DECEMBER 27:  Shaheen Afridi of Pakistan celebrates after dismissing Temba Bavuma of South Africa during day 2 of the 1st Castle Lager Test match between South Africa and Pakistan at SuperSport Park on December 27, 2018 in Pretoria, South Africa. (Photo by Sydney Seshibedi/Gallo Images)
Image: Shaheen Afridi was left disappointed after finding Dean Elgar's edge

A huge roar emanated from the Centurion crowd when Wilson's decision was revealed on the big screen, while Pakistan's players looked absolutely dumbfounded at Elgar's reprieve.

Pakistan coach Mickey Arthur's frustrated reaction to the call - the ICC said he "showed dissent" towards Wilson before "storming out" of the TV umpire's room - saw him given one demerit point.

An ICC statement read: "Arthur, after TV umpire Joel Wilson had decided in favour of Dean Elgar, entered the TV umpire's room and showed dissent at Mr Wilson's decision by first questioning him and then storming out of the room.

Also See:

"After the match, the Pakistan coach admitted the offence and accepted the sanction proposed by match referee David Boon. As such, there was no need for a formal hearing."

Pakistan's coach Mickey Arthur speaks during a press conference folling a nets practice session at The Oval in London on June 17, 2017, on the eve of the I
Image: Mickey Arthur was charged with dissent for his reaction to Joel Wilson's decision

Speaking on the live commentary, Michael Holding said: "I'm convinced he was out. I think the third umpire made a mistake. The protocol says you have got to be 100 percent sure the decision was wrong to change it."

Elgar was on four at the time and went on to score 50 as South Africa reached their victory target of 149 to win by six wickets - Hashim Amla top-scoring with an unbeaten 63 in the Proteas' second innings.

Watch day one of the second Test between South Africa and Pakistan, live on Sky Sports Cricket from 8.25am on Thursday, January 3.

Around Sky