Skip to content

South Africa v England: 'Bring Stuart Broad back for Johannesburg ODI'

England beaten by seven wickets in third ODI in Centurion...

Image: Stuart Broad last played an ODI for England at the 2015 World Cup in the spring of 2015

Nick Knight hopes Stuart Broad returns to the England side for the fourth one-day international in Johannesburg.

An inexperienced England attack struggled in slipping to a seven-wicket defeat to South Africa in Centurion on Tuesday, with Quinton de Kock (135) and Hashim Amla (127) scoring high-class centuries as the hosts successfully chased 318.

The loss means England have been pegged back in the series, leading 2-1 with two games to play.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Watch a pick of the action from the third ODI between South Africa and England

"It's hard to be critical of the bowling," said Knight. "But they're all inexperienced lads - there was no Broad in there - and these guys are all still learning their trade.

"Amla and De Kock were quite brilliant - the way they constructed their partnership - and it was such a masterclass that you felt that they would chase pretty much anything down.

 Quinton de Kock and Hashim Amla of South Africa during the 3rd ODI
Image: Quinton de Kock (L) and Hashim Amla (R) were the stars for South Africa in their third ODI win

"It was about whether England could take early wickets, and they couldn't. The bowlers tried absolutely everything, as did Eoin Morgan.

"He tried to rotate his bowlers, but never quite found a combination where he could stymie the runs, push the required-rate up and put pressure on.

Also See:

"Again that's partly down to the skill of the batsmen, but let's face it, without a Steven Finn, Liam Plunkett or a Broad, Morgan is slightly hamstrung - he doesn't have that extra pace to try and change the game.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Eoin Morgan, AB de Villiers and Quinton de Kock share their thoughts after England suffered a seven wicket defeat to South Africa in the third ODI

"There was a time when some of those young kids, in the heat of the battle out there, need an experienced hand on their shoulder to say 'this is what we're going to try and do, and how we're going to do it'.

"It's no secret - I said it before the series started - I would have gone with Broad. I would have rested him for the last Test, and played him in the ODIs, not all five games, but the first three.

Live One-Day International Cricket

"Ironically, I think he would have bowled really well on that surface, as there was a slight difference between the way the two sides bowled - South Africa had a much taller attack, with the likes of Morne Morkel, Kagiso Rabada, and Kyle Abbott hitting the pitch just back of a length.

"They got a little bit more from the surface. Conditions were in their favour, as the pitch got better, and the England bowlers were a little bit fuller, and didn't have quite the same pace.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Watch England skittle South Africa for just 83 runs in their third Test win in Johannesburg, with Stuart Broad taking six wickets

"Don't forget, it was a game South Africa had to win to stay in the series, so it was a tremendous performance from two high quality players with a huge amount of pressure on both of them.

"It has set up the rest of the series beautifully going into Johannesburg. Broad bowled brilliantly there in the Test match taking 6-17, and I hope they bring him back, because they could knock the series on the head with a win there."

Will South Africa square up the series in Johannesburg on Friday? Find out from 11am on Sky Sports 2. You can also follow all the action with our live blog.

Around Sky