Rory McIlroy is box office, but he isn't Tiger Woods, says Sky Sports' Wayne Riley after Wentworth play-off loss

Rory McIlroy was beaten by Billy Horschel at the second play-off hole in the BMW PGA Championship at Wentworth; McIlory birdied the 18th hole before Horschel eagled it; Sky Sports Golf's Wayne Riley believes fans are expecting too much of McIlroy and might be comparing him to Tiger Woods

By Wayne Riley, Golf Expert

Nick Dougherty and Wayne Riley dissect Rory McIlroy's final-day performance at the BMW PGA Championship and discuss just how long it will be before he claims another victory

Wayne Riley hailed "box office" Rory McIlroy but added that Tiger Woods was "in a different stratosphere" to the world No 3 after his latest near-miss at Wentworth.

McIlroy missed out on a second BMW PGA Championship title as Billy Horschel prevailed in a thrilling play-off finish, one week on from also being edged out at the Irish Open by Rasmus Hojgaard over the closing stages.

It adds to a season of agonising finishes for McIlroy, which includes him faltering down the stretch in pursuit of a fifth major at the US Open, and Riley believes the expectations placed on McIlroy are too much from fans.

"He finishes eagle, birdie, so that guy down there [who said Rory bottled it] should hang his head in shame," Riley said.

It all came down to the second play-off hole between McIlroy and Billy Horschel to decide who would claim the 2024 BMW PGA Championship

"If this guy was a bottle job, that is just pure class. He was out of it kind of and he played his way back into it.

Advertisement

"That is what you get from McIlroy, you get box office, you get pure theatre. He is just a great player, everybody loves him.

"At the end of the day, we saw a great player in Tiger Woods and he was in a different stratosphere and they expect Rory to be like that. It isn't going to happen.

Also See:

"He has won twice on the PGA Tour [this year] and that is not easy to do. McIlroy is McIlroy so everyone should leave him alone."

Also discussing McIlroy's latest near miss was former PGA champion Rich Beem. "It will weigh on him," he told Sky Sports.

"He's a competitor at the highest level and he wants to win every time he tees it up - it's just not possible.

"People want to slay the giants and Rory is definitely a giant in this game, so people want to take him down.

"He is going to get knocked down a bunch more in his career but he is going to dust himself off, get back up and get right back into the fight."

Highlights from day four of the BMW PGA Championship at Wentworth Golf Club

Beem added: "It didn't sound like he had his best body of work out there, he grinded it out.

"He made that eagle on the 17th that propelled him and gave him an opportunity to win this thing outright but he just couldn't get it done.

"I don't look at it as much as losing. Coming off the heels of a very disappointing loss last week, getting in the play-offs and giving himself a chance, that's nothing to get down about. He just came up a little bit shy."

McIlroy: I am playing well and will dust myself off

McIlroy himself was not disappointed in his performance at Wentworth and believes he did well to draw himself back into the contest.

Indeed, he is ready to "dust himself off" and get ready for the final three events of the year.

McIlroy reflects on his performance and the positives he is taking away from it

"I felt like down the stretch I was a bit scrappy. I was missing greens but not by that much and I felt a little bit off, especially with the irons," McIlroy told Sky Sports.

"I had a good iron shot into 14 and converted that and I felt like I played certainly the last three or four holes very well. I just didn't convert the putts.

"A bonus on 17 with the eagle that got me right back in it, then I just had awkward yardage on 18.

McIlroy made a great putt for an eagle on the 17th hole of the BMW PGA Championship to take a share of the lead

"With what I am trying to do with my golf swing, I kind of revert back to old habits when I am under the gun like everyone does.

"I think if I keep working on the things I am working on on the range, that only bodes well for the future.

"To work on my swing but still go out there and have a really good chance to win, I am proud of that.

This is a limited version of the story so unfortunately this content is not available.
Open the full version

"I am excited for the future. I am playing well, I keep giving myself chances.

"Only two people have beat me in the last two weeks or only one person I guess in terms of scores.

"I am happy with how I am playing. I just have to dust myself off and get myself ready for the last three events of the year."

Sky Sports+ has officially launched and will be integrated into Sky TV, streaming service NOW and the Sky Sports app, giving Sky Sports customers access to over 50 per cent more live sport this year at no extra cost. Find out more here.

Outbrain